Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- fantasy_rpg_design_challenge [2016/08/15 08:32] – Added winner for 3rd challenge brent
+++ fantasy_rpg_design_challenge [2016/08/16 18:26] (current) – Added Brent's advice brent
@@ Line 130: / Line 130: @@
   * [[https://plus.google.com/u/0/112234386288014033364|Jesse Cox]]'s **[[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lCq---UyhXvd7oPZ6LFhcBWKwyWkg_LNGy61ihk-1jo/edit|LunAurora]]**
+===== Brent's Advice, Buried at the Bottom of the Page =====
+What I Judge For:
+  * **Completeness** - Is this a playable game? Are gray areas and common difficulties addressed? Are any important game aids included (character sheets, play mats, etc.)?
+  * **Comprehensibility** - Do I understand how to play the game? Does the text move clearly from introduction to explanation to details? Do complex mechanics come with examples? Do player-characters have a defined role in the world (or is the concept at least addressed)?
+  * **Creativity** - Does this feel fantastic? Is the setting concrete and “of a whole”? How similar is it to well-known concepts? Does it go too far into obscure weirdness?
+What I Care Less About:
+  * **Polish** - cool images and such are nice but all the winners have had straightforward, Google Docs-level formatting
+Bonus Points:
+  * A compelling concept that addresses a real personal/social issue (without getting too icky)
+  * Minimal physical combat (it’s just been done so much)
+Advice:
+  * Include your name, a license, and a list of games that inspired you (if any).